The Daily Illini
URL: http://www.dailyillini.com/index.php/article/2006/08/column_unions_relics_of_the_past_taxpayer_frustration
Current Date: Thu, 09 Feb 2012 18:01:34 -0600
Column: Unions: Relics of the past, taxpayer frustration
It's the time of year when the annual contracts for University employees are renewed and the unions are out in force complaining that workers are on the verge of starvation and poverty because of big, bad University administrators. The reality is that this is far from the truth.
Take the perennial attempts to unionize the non-visiting academic professionals as an example. The Association of Academic Professionals have complaints such as "unfair or nonexistent policies", an inability to present grievances to employers and job protection rights. As for policies, one could say the University has too many policies. Grievances can be presented to the Council of Academic Professionals, or people can do it the old fashioned way: talk to your boss directly. As for job protection, most academic professionals in all but the most extreme cases need to be given a full year's notice when they are fired. For instance, a campus parking employee who was charged with stealing from the University was put on paid leave for eleven months before he was finally terminated (The charges were eventually dropped). Academic professionals are also given ten weeks paid leave per year. These are far from the dangerous factory jobs of last century.
While there is a small and vocal minority of instigators trying to start a union, most people see past the absurdity of the AAP's claims of harsh working conditions. Some surely object to having part of their paycheck sent to the National Educator's Association to exclusively support the election of liberal democrats. After all, less than 10 of the NEA's 95 action items actually had to do with education. So low is the support that only about 18 percent of visiting academic professionals voted to unionize.
Then, there are the ubiquitous complaints of the Graduate Employees Organization. The billboards around town are a great example stating only 40 percent of graduate students can afford health care for their children. First off, 40 percent doesn't pass the smell test because I highly doubt 40 percent of graduate students even have children. However, even if the number is accurate, there is a buffet of programs to provide health care for children. There is Medicaid, Kid Care and Rod Blagojevich's new All Kids plan. There are also the free medical clinics Frances Nelson and the Champaign County Christian Healthcare Center. If the government-run programs simply do not meet the needs of poor graduate students, and by extension poor people, I'd be more than happy to have that money returned to my paycheck.
The idea that part-time, limited-term, and transient employees need to be provided a living wage in return for getting an acceptance letter is specious at best. If the threshold for a living wage is only 10 hours a week, we would be working even less than the French. For reference, 25 percent of graduate assistants in the University Library make about $14/hr. In Physics, 25 percent of teaching assistants make $18. This is not a bad wage for a part-time employee. However, when you add into this the lucrative tuition and fee waivers they receive, library assistants get paid $36/hr and in Physics they get $40/hr. How much does the GEO want this increased? $100/hr? Health insurance for one or more children for graduate students runs $114/month. Insurance for full-time employees for 2 or more dependents runs $114/month. Do we really need to be giving better benefits to students than we give to faculty and staff? This also does not include the $100/semester credit for health insurance that graduate students get.
Being a student is hard and you have to get by on a small amount of money; however, the primary beneficiary of an advanced degree is the person getting that degree. While supporting a family on part-time employment is impossible almost anywhere else, at least it is only difficult at the University.
The fact is, unions on this campus are nothing more than an added expense placed on taxpayers and students. University unions, and public-sector unions in general, have largely hijacked the legacy of the unions from the days when they were necessary. You, dear readers, are picking up the tab.
Most Popular
- Memes, Y U so addicting?! |
2/7/2012 - 7:42 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives - Despite another ring, Eli is still not as good as Peyton |
2/7/2012 - 1:58 PM
Posted in: DI Sports Wrap-Up - For better or for worse |
2/2/2012 - 6:43 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives - Don’t sleep on the Big 12 |
2/1/2012 - 12:23 AM
Posted in: DI Sports Wrap-Up - Eli Manning and Tom Brady represent the unstoppable passage of time |
1/30/2012 - 7:23 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives
- Troyer accepts full-time employment in department of psychology | 5 comments
- Not all users ‘like’ the Facebook timeline | 4 comments
- Note to Occupy participants: Peace is stronger | 6 comments
- Email scandal occupies center stage | 5 comments
- Obama should take his cues from Brazilian president Rousseff | 15 comments
- Mike on Tea Party prioritizes tone over substance in GOP candidates
- undemeGuece on Illinois Safe Schools Alliance forum addresses LGBT bullying codes in schools
- Steve on Students should be aware of companies labor practices abroad
- oven21 on What should you do with your significant other this Valentine’s Day?
- Kenneth Goldberg, Ph.D. on Unique bonds formed in Illini Mentor Program








Reader Comments
Be the first to comment on this article!
Post new comment
You Should Know: The Daily Illini reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.
Comments will not appear until approved by a site moderator.