The Daily Illini
URL: http://www.dailyillini.com/index.php/article/2008/08/judge_cook_county_jail_strip_search_unconstitutional
Current Date: Thu, 09 Feb 2012 16:23:21 -0600
Judge: Cook County Jail strip search unconstitutional
CHICAGO - A federal judge ruled Thursday that the Cook County Jail's policy of giving male inmates one last strip search before releasing them from custody violated their constitutional rights.
The practice violates both the Fourth Amendment guarantee against unreasonable searches and the Fourteenth Amendment's assurance of equal protection under the law, said U.S. District Judge Elaine E. Bucklo.
She ruled in a four-year-old suit filed by Quentin Bullock and Jack Reid, two former inmates who were acquitted of charges in court but still strip searched before being released from the jail.
The sheriff's office, which oversees the jail, fought the lawsuit, saying a final strip search was necessary for security.
"We don't agree with it (the ruling) and we will seek a court review," said Penny Mateck, a spokeswoman for Sheriff Tom Dart.
Jail officials say inmates who have been acquitted by a court cannot simply be released. They have to be returned to the jail where officials run a check to determine if there are other, unrelated charges outstanding that might keep them behind bars.
Such prisoners might smuggle weapons or other contraband back into the jail and leave it with other inmates, officials say.
But the jail has long followed a practice of not strip searching female inmates who return before discharge. They are kept in a separate holding area while officials run checks to see if they are ready for release.
"Defendants argue that they have no animus toward male discharges, that their motivation is simply to preclude weapons and contraband from being smuggled into the jail," Bucklo wrote in her 23-page decision.
"As already set forth and admitted by defendants, however, female discharges are also capable of smuggling contraband into the jail," she said. "This salient fact fatally undermines defendants' argument."
Four bullpens capable of holding 120 inmates each during the wait to be discharged would cost $50,000 to $200,000 to build, Bucklo said.
It was the latest blow to what officials call the nation's largest county jail located on a single site.
A 17-month federal investigation made public July 17 said serious sanitation and medical care problems exist in the jail, as well as violence directed against prisoners who clashed with guards or failed to follow commands.
Most Popular
- Memes, Y U so addicting?! |
2/7/2012 - 7:42 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives - Despite another ring, Eli is still not as good as Peyton |
2/7/2012 - 1:58 PM
Posted in: DI Sports Wrap-Up - For better or for worse |
2/2/2012 - 6:43 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives - Don’t sleep on the Big 12 |
2/1/2012 - 12:23 AM
Posted in: DI Sports Wrap-Up - Eli Manning and Tom Brady represent the unstoppable passage of time |
1/30/2012 - 7:23 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives
- Troyer accepts full-time employment in department of psychology | 5 comments
- Not all users ‘like’ the Facebook timeline | 4 comments
- Note to Occupy participants: Peace is stronger | 6 comments
- Email scandal occupies center stage | 5 comments
- Obama should take his cues from Brazilian president Rousseff | 15 comments
- Dirk on Tea Party prioritizes tone over substance in GOP candidates
- Fascinating on California stays true to character in overturning Proposition 8
- Michael on RSO to host third annual drag show
- Illinois Psychology on Troyer accepts full-time employment in department of psychology
- Chris S on Popular condiment healthy in moderation despite reputation







Reader Comments
Be the first to comment on this article!
Post new comment
You Should Know: The Daily Illini reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.
Comments will not appear until approved by a site moderator.