Emergency messaging effectiveness questioned

Post a comment
Cody Westerlund  Contact me
Posted: June 24, 2009 - 12:00 AM
Updated: June 25, 2009 - 10:56 PM
Tagged with: alert, Campus, emergency, Illini Alert system, mass e mail, Mike Corn, severe weather, text message, Todd Short
Printer Friendly
 
A tree lies in pieces in Scott Park after severe storms came through the area on Friday. The University's Illini Alert sent out emails and text messages warning of a possible tornado in the area

Possibly Related


Illini Alert, a system of communication via text messages and e-mails that are sent out to registered students and faculty in emergency situations, was activated to notify the University community about severe weather around 7 p.m. Friday.

It was the first time the alert system was used to warn of hazardous weather conditions. The text messages said, "Emergency! Tornado expected to hit UI campus. Seek shelter indoors immediately and turn to local media for details."

As it was, a tornado never touched down on campus or in Champaign-Urbana. There was damage in the area due to the high winds and heavy rains. Regardless of the result, though, Todd Short, the director of emergency planning in the Division of Public Safety, said the decision to send out an alert is simple. It's all based on the local tornado sirens.

"If the sirens sound for Champaign County, we send out a full campus alert," Short said, adding the public safety branch in the police department makes the decision to sound the sirens.

The reason for what some may deem as drastic wording in the text message – "Emergency! Tornado expected to hit UI campus" – was that the experts thought there was a good chance a tornado would hit. Short said storm spotters in Savoy, Champaign, Tolono and Philo "observed a wall cloud ... that had the rotation in it that was lowering, which is a probable tornado."

Short said about 33,000 text messages and 116,000 e-mails were being sent out simultaneously. Many students who are signed up for the service likely weren't on campus but still received the message. That's something that cannot be avoided, Short said.

"We can't subdivide a full-campus alert, so it's an all-or-nothing proposition," Short said.

Mike Corn, chief privacy and security officer in the Office of the CIO, oversees the technical side of the Illini Alert. He said if some registered users of the service didn't receive the warning message, the problem did not originate with the Illini Alert system.

"999 times out of 1,000, when a message isn't received, we've sent it," Corn said. "We hand it off to whoever your carrier is, and at that point, who knows? When we send an e-mail, it leaves our system and we have a record showing it was sent out of our system at a certain time. We can't guarantee it will show up in your inbox."

Corn said text messages are even harder to track because there's no way to know what happens once they are sent out to carriers. But, he added, almost all messages are correctly sent out.

Even though a tornado didn't hit, Short said he was "150 percent" certain the right call had been made.

"We have to err on the side of caution," Short said. "Anybody that's lived in the Midwest and has to deal with tornado activity (knows) it's impossible for us to predict the path of a storm ... The last thing we want to do is fail to take an action that would advocate personal protective actions by the people that are counting on us to notify them of a potential emergency."

Post a comment

Reader Comments

uofi899

Flag this comment

the problem is the amount of time to send them out. i was having dinner with my family when my sister got the message, it said to to to a basement i think or something like that. the point is, i got mine over 20 mins later, it may have been too late for me.

justanotherguy

Flag this comment

Unfortunately, the user's text messaging service or cell phone provider sometimes have huge gaps between the time a message is sent and the time the end-user ultimately receives it.

I have no working knowledge of exactly how the systems work, but I do know that individual messages between me and other family members can often be delayed for up to 30 minutes. It stands to reason that if a company is trying to process thousands of messages at the same time, it will take longer to get the message through to the end-user.

I don't have a problem with the logic of this message -- the tornado warning sirens were sounding in Champaign County and that should be an automatic trigger for the system.

The "controversy" over this specific message is another clear indication of the problems associated with running a system like this. If there had been no message, but a tornado did hit, people would be up in arms about it. If the message is sent out in good faith and there's no tornada, it's viewed as an inconvenience or aggravation.

People can always unsubscribe and take their chances on their own....

Post new comment

You Should Know: The Daily Illini reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.

Comments will not appear until approved by a site moderator.

Formatting Options:
  • Links: "my link":http://my.url.com
  • Bold: *something!*
  • Italic: _OMG!_