The Daily Illini
URL: http://www.dailyillini.com/index.php/blog/different_perspectives/2009/11/university_gives_false_impression_that_striking_means_not_caring
Current Date: Wed, 08 Feb 2012 11:56:17 -0600
University gives false impression that striking means not caring
There are some lines you just don’t cross.
Or at least, lines you shouldn’t cross unless you have a really, really good reason and there’s no getting around it – like the line in front of Best Buy on Black Friday. Or, y’know, picket lines.
Or the invisible line in disagreements and controversies – the one you cross with a carelessly flung comment only to realize a moment later that you’ve gone too far and there’s no going back. This is the kind of crossed line that, depending on who you’re talking to, leads to things like being grounded, getting the silent treatment, the oh-no-you-didn’ts, crying and apologizing to Sarah Palin on your talk show.
You could say there have been a lot of lines crossed in the University’s spat with the Graduate Employees’ Organization, and both sides have accused the other of misrepresenting the situation and either overhyping or making light of certain facts. But the University has been toeing one of those “do not cross” lines recently.
The Daily Illini recently asked University spokeswoman Robin Kaler some questions about the situation. In response to a question about what to do if a student gets to class and there is no teacher, Kaler begins with, “We would hope assistants respect their instructional obligations and do not impair students’ progress in their current courses.”
Well, obviously, if there is a strike and a student is in a course taught by a graduate assistant, that student’s progress will be impaired. But Kaler offers up a false dichotomy when she says that the University hopes “assistants respect their instructional obligations” and not impair progress, which striking obviously does. The message I get is that graduate employees who strike don’t care.
That’s also the message I’ve heard graduate employees recoiling from. Whenever I’ve heard graduate employees addressing the situation, all of them have stressed that they really don’t want to have to strike – and that undergraduate education is still important to them. Most of my classes last week were prefaced with tense little conversations about the strike (basically, the instructor laying out what will happen and students’ hands flying up to ascertain the future of their grades, or else sitting back and imagining being asleep that time next week).
The GEO’s dispute with the University is a labor dispute. It’s an issue of wages, waivers and other benefits, not a commentary on whether GEO employees take their jobs seriously.
The University has not suggested that wages are down because of the caliber of instruction and assistant these employees offer; all the arguments boil down to the budget.
So, as in any argument where you have to live with someone after the fact, the University should make sure it sticks to the issues at hand because once you cross a line, you can’t take it back.
Rachel is a junior in Media.
About Different Perspectives
On a college campus of 40,000 unique individuals, opinions differ on every subject. The Daily Illini strives to encourage a wide-range of thoughts and ideas that harnesses the diversity of the University. Enter Different Perspective, a blog that captures the differing thoughts on campus through a hand-selected group of talented writers with strong opinions from all sides of the spectrum. On it you’ll find both lengthy, thoughtful pieces and random musings, as well as other topics that spark debate. And if you don’t agree, just comment back. Speak up UI. We know we will.
Subscribe with RSSRecent Posts
Most Popular
- Memes, Y U so addicting?! |
2/7/2012 - 7:42 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives - Despite another ring, Eli is still not as good as Peyton |
2/7/2012 - 1:58 PM
Posted in: DI Sports Wrap-Up - For better or for worse |
2/2/2012 - 6:43 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives - Don’t sleep on the Big 12 |
2/1/2012 - 12:23 AM
Posted in: DI Sports Wrap-Up - Eli Manning and Tom Brady represent the unstoppable passage of time |
1/30/2012 - 7:23 PM
Posted in: Different Perspectives
- Not all users ‘like’ the Facebook timeline | 3 comments
- Letter to the editor: Which side are you on, DI? | 3 comments
- Note to Occupy participants: Peace is stronger | 6 comments
- Email scandal occupies center stage | 5 comments
- Obama should take his cues from Brazilian president Rousseff | 15 comments
- Caitlin on ‘Finger-wagging’ by UN fails to show authority
- Leo M. Schwaiger on Filmmaker starts week as Allen’s Guest-in-Residence
- Rania on Not all users ‘like’ the Facebook timeline
- Miguel Arroyo on Not all users ‘like’ the Facebook timeline
- Dawn on Not all users ‘like’ the Facebook timeline





Reader Comments
Flag this comment
Rachel, thank you for this piece. The false dichotomy you observe--you're either on strike OR you care about undergrad students, but not both--is the most heartbreaking thing about the administration's message to me and many other GEO members. Even though we know our students are super intelligent and can't be fooled by such an obviously false argument, it's still incredibly reassuring to see evidence of this in print. Keep spreading the message!
Flag this comment
Thanks for understanding, Rachel. I have been worrying since the strike was first proposed about if my students would feel abandoned.
Post new comment
You Should Know: The Daily Illini reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.
Comments will not appear until approved by a site moderator.