Avatar: Pocahontas meets internet-age sci fi

Post a comment
James VandeBerg  Contact me
January 18, 2010 - 12:02 AM

Overall rating: 3.3/4

Have you heard about Avatar? No? Well, let me explain.

It's that new James Cameron movie that is going to change cinema. It's going to change how movies are produced, marketed, merchandised, all of that. That's what people have been saying anyway. Even commentators who were strongly anti-Avatar, such as Gawker entertainment writer Brian Moylan, changed their tune after seeing the movie. It was supposed to be that good.

Was it?

I've been trying to formulate my opinion for a day now. I'm a confessed ex-Avatar hater myself, and up until about a week ago one of my primary interests was talking about how much of a disaster this movie was going to be. I'm generally not a sci-fi fan, and outer space seems kind of tedious. I don't really have a solid reason — it's just one of those things. By the time Avatar actually got here, though, my position had softened to the point where I was actually excited to see the movie and was hoping it would turn out well.

I was decently satisfied. The movie is certainly pretty, and Cameron isn't afraid to show Pandora off; the scenes where the magical tree seeds glow — along with basically everything else — are deliciously indulgent. Watching the Na'vi and the humans battle it out in hand to hand combat lives up to every expectation (you're waiting for this to happen after about half an hour). Most of the hype surrounding the movie is based on the special effects, and they certainly are beautiful, but I'm having a hard time calling it groundbreaking and game-changing.

That level of hyperbole is tricky. The effects are obviously very good, and it's neat to see computer generated aliens and actual filmed humans duking it out and having it look completely realistic, but it was going to happen soon enough, Avatar or not.

Since we've all heard about the special effects enough, a look at the plot could be a little more productive. The movie had been portrayed by many as an environmental commentary, an examination of the wrongs of modern society and the damage we're doing. I think WALL-E did a better job of that than Avatar. What we have here is a commentary on race and imperialism mixed with a little bit of technological foresight. Many have compared Avatar to Dances with Wolves, and I think the comparison is completely valid.

I'm going to go with Pocahontas as another paralleling story. We have a man coming over with invading forces into a peaceful, nature-loving society. Man learns native culture, man falls in love with native woman. Isn't that groundbreaking? I found myself watching the movie and thinking, "Wait a second! This isn't about the environment at all! This is just the colonization of America with better technology!" Just as in Titanic, the plot is an utterly predictable, "good enough" vehicle for Cameron to show off all his toys. Is there anything wrong with that?

I'm willing to excuse all of this on one condition — Kevin Costner was not switching back and forth between his human existence and that of a totally different being every fifteen minutes or so. It honestly gets confusing after a while. Is Jake Sully still Jake? Is he his avatar? Talk about an existential crisis. In a world where we half-exist through texting, Gchat, and Facebook, and half-exist in face-to-face "real life," this is something worth thinking about. Do we have a choice about who we want to be? Will we eventually be able to just control another body if we decide that's more worthwhile? For our ex-Marine hero, the choice is easy enough — he plugs into Eywa and his soul is transplanted into a Na'vi body, leaving his human existence behind.

That's the easy solution to the problem, but what if Eywa wasn't so giving? What if he had to step out of the avatar machine eventually, and confront the society he had turned against, as himself? What if he didn't get the girl (admittedly after a bit of identity and species switching)? Now that would have been a interesting movie.

Post a comment

Reader Comments

blazearmoru

Flag this comment

Haha. Yea! I had the EXACT same thoughts throughout the movie, except my reason for hating on avatar in the beginning was cus I thought about air blender... I watched it anyway on whim and soon I got blown away by the graphics and just how beautiful the environment was, but soon I realized it was about people invading a slightly different nation with the excuse of "giving" while actually scamming, stealing, and finally robbing everything they had. The movie was good, the ideas I find funny, but I too felt the ending would of been better if it had not been so sweet. If it had been more bittersweet or darker, like how it actually happened time and time again in reality in our history, maybe people would notice it rather than just think "yay, beautiful love story ^_^". Hate Hollywood endings. ~_~

But really, the ending though. Did you realize "Man" stole the native's engaged wife? Even if the ending looked this sweet, i'm pretty sure the natives will soon be corrupted from within. =P

blazearmoru

Flag this comment

Haha. Yea! I had the EXACT same thoughts throughout the movie, except my reason for hating on avatar in the beginning was cus I thought about air blender... I watched it anyway on whim and soon I got blown away by the graphics and just how beautiful the environment was, but soon I realized it was about people invading a slightly different nation with the excuse of "giving" while actually scamming, stealing, and finally robbing everything they had. The movie was good, the ideas I find funny, but I too felt the ending would of been better if it had not been so sweet. If it had been more bittersweet or darker, like how it actually happened time and time again in reality in our history, maybe people would notice it rather than just think "yay, beautiful love story ^_^". Hate Hollywood endings. ~_~

But really, the ending though. Did you realize "Man" stole the native's engaged wife? Even if the ending looked this sweet, i'm pretty sure the natives will soon be corrupted from within. =P

Frank

Flag this comment

I go with Pocahontas but Dances with Wolves might do as well. As for the 3d effect it was like looking at several flat 2d segments in a row, which gave a stuttering effect at certain rapid movements. It might have been better to watch it in Imax.

Harrison

Flag this comment

I saw the film and liked it. I would not compare it with other films as they had different backdrops and objectives. Avatar has its script and the the 'intended' effects are very much original like the films people have described above.

Denise

Flag this comment

Avatar's plot is just like Disney's Pocahontas. In Pocahontas you encounter John Smith who is brought to the New World to steal the lands gold. John falls in love with the Native Pocahontas who is the Native Chief's daughter and set to marry the island's greatest warrior. The Native's just like the Na'vi seek insight from the great tree spirit, Mother Willow. All in all I must say that although I did feel like I was watching the same storyline as Pocahontas... The feelings I experienced watching Pocahontas no where compare to those I felt watching Avatar. James Cameron is brilliant and his film will change the way we watch movies from this day forward. Avatar was visually the most fantastic movie I have ever seen!!! I think everyone should experience it's beauty and open their mind to the message of the film.

jngeirscashhioaclmae

Flag this comment

okay so yeah Avatar IS like Pocahontas and Dances With Wolves BUT what movie doesnt resemble another.. The Reason they are all similar is because they are ALL based on fact that it is happening again and again.. Granted we arent out to ruin the home of extremely large blue people BUT we are taking land for natural resources every single day AND taking land from its natives that has not and does not belong to us .. I think think these reasons pretty much explain why they are all similiar.

TooMuchTimeOnHands

Flag this comment

I haven't checked it out for myself yet but according to "geek" sources, Avatar IS Pochahontas....we're talking word for word almost...guess I'll have to watch Pochahontas and then see Avatar myself....

Scott

Flag this comment

Well we as a society, (And I mean world-wide) have been stripping the planet of its natural resources for millenia, now we've achieved the capability of doing so in RAPID fashion and its going to bite us in the butt. The furthur we chop into the rain forests the more ebola and other nifty dieases we're going to uncover and spread. Ultimately I think we're going to have a mass die-off of humans that will return the balance to our world. Right now we need about 4 billion less than the 6.5 that we have now of human life on this planet. That would make things more comfortable for all of us.

s

theidkid

Flag this comment

Of course it's like Pocahontas and Dances with Wolves. It's also like Star Wars and every other movie that's ever used the hero's journey as a plot. Cameron was playing it safe by using this particular plot. People love it and it almost never fails.

Anonymous2142

Flag this comment

Just for clarity the aliens were actually NOT fully computer generated then dubbed over. In reality the alien voice actors wore sensors all over their body while being filmed, later they used the sensors to "build" the alien body on top of them.

AVATAR?

Flag this comment

Do you not understand? The fact that AVATAR's storyline is nearly exactly the same as Pocahontas's is in itself a comment on society and the environment. The end is exactly the opposite- Jake Sully must change himself and completely immerse himself into the Na'vi culture for there to be a 'happy ending', whereas in Pocahontas, she leaves with Smith to the city, where she is changed into an 'american woman'- dresses and all. Perhaps then Cameron's message was that we need to rethink our motives when it comes to the environment. Look what happened to the american indians; they were destroyed, and now america is one of the most polluting countries in the world. Cameron seems to be saying that we have to rethink our ideologies and start believing in enviromentalism if we want a 'happy ending' for ourselves. come on- it's an awesome film. how often do you get romance, environment, action and fantasy all in one film when it WORKS! give him some credit guys, i can tell u it's gonna be a classic. xx

Public Enenemy

Flag this comment

Change the way we see movies? C'mon the effects were good and all, but I am not so surprised. I saw more groundbraking from Matrix. Anyway the plot is so bad and cliche that I felt like watching comedy. Specially the Colonel, I laughed evrytime he talked. He is a walking cliche. You know what is even funnier on this movie. The so called nature loving society of the blue people, actually needed humans to save thei asses and all. I guess we are not that bad. I can't believe people got that excited about this movie. I'd rather read a good book.

Post new comment

You Should Know: The Daily Illini reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.

Comments will not appear until approved by a site moderator.

Formatting Options:
  • Links: "my link":http://my.url.com
  • Bold: *something!*
  • Italic: _OMG!_